Calif's 'Nick Shirley Law' In Hands of Courts Or Washington

Republicans and congressional allies are asking the Justice Department to block California’s newly signed AB 2624, the privacy law they call the “Stop Nick Shirley Act,” saying it will chill investigations of alleged fraud at immigrant-serving nonprofits. 

Democrats and Gov. Gavin Newsom say it only extends an existing confidentiality program to workers facing threats and doxxing. Newsom signed the bill Aug. 22. It takes effect Oct. 1, 2027.

Assemblymember Carl DeMaio coined the nickname and asked DOJ to intervene; nine House Republicans followed with a letter to Attorney General Todd Blanche. Last week, YouTuber Nick Shirley rallied with GOP lawmakers at the Capitol, arguing Democrats created a “protected class” after his videos alleged fraud in Minnesota day cares and California hospices. A scuffle produced two arrests. 

The measure passed on party lines. Author Mia Bonta said service workers “are living in fear.” Newsom’s office said the law “has nothing to do with Nick Shirley.” 

Critics note she introduced it after Shirley’s reporting; supporters cite rising threats amid immigration politics. AB 2624 lets documented-threat victims use a substitute address on public records and allows civil suits for posting images or personal data with intent to incite imminent harm. It does not name journalists. 

Opponents still say the mix of secrecy and penalties will deter video investigations; Democrats say that claim is a smear. 

The fight now runs through courts and Washington.