Thursday, November 19, 2026

MAD Project Presses Court to Force FCC Action


The Media and Democracy Project (MAD) has filed a reply brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, urging the court to compel the FCC to act on its long-pending appeal challenging the license renewal of Fox-owned television station WTXF in Philadelphia.

The filing responds to the FCC's opposition to MAD's petition for a writ of mandamus and argues that FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has already publicly defended the agency's dismissal of MAD's original Petition to Deny before both Congress and the courts. According to MAD, the FCC has nevertheless declined to issue a final commission order that would allow the organization to seek judicial review.

In its filing, MAD contends that the commission has effectively reached a decision on the matter and needs only to issue a final order formally denying relief so the group can challenge that determination in court.

The organization also accuses the FCC of treating complaints involving major broadcast networks inconsistently. MAD points to the agency's rapid action to revive complaints involving ABC, CBS and NBC shortly after President Donald Trump and Chairman Carr took office, while its challenge to Fox's license renewal has remained unresolved.

MAD argues that the FCC failed to address allegations that political considerations may be influencing the agency's handling of the case. The group claims the commission's response does not rebut assertions that the delay reflects favorable treatment toward Fox and its chairman, Rupert Murdoch, a longtime Trump ally.

The filing further disputes the FCC's contention that the matter is too complex to resolve quickly. MAD argues that the agency has not demonstrated that substantial work is being conducted on the appeal or identified competing priorities that would justify the prolonged delay.



According to MAD, the commission's inaction is particularly notable given its stated emphasis on enforcing broadcasters' public-interest obligations and character qualifications. The group maintains that those policies are directly relevant to its challenge and should warrant prompt consideration of the application.

As relief, MAD is asking the court to order the FCC to act on its Application for Review or, alternatively, permit discovery into the reasons behind the agency's delay.

The dispute dates back to July 2023, when MAD challenged the renewal of WTXF's broadcast license, citing findings that emerged from Dominion Voting Systems' litigation against Fox and arguing that the evidence raised questions under the Communications Act's character requirements for broadcast license holders. The case has since become a closely watched test of how the FCC addresses challenges to broadcasters' public-interest obligations and license qualifications.