Nexstar Media Group Inc. urged a federal appeals court on Tuesday to allow it to operate 33 of Tegna Inc.’s 64 television stations that are not at issue in an ongoing antitrust lawsuit, seeking to narrow a lower-court order that has kept the two companies operating separately until trial.
Nexstar lawyer Deanne Maynard told a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit that U.S. District Judge Troy L. Nunley in Sacramento erred when he ordered the companies to remain fully separate pending a trial next year on whether their $6.2 billion merger violates antitrust law. “The most they would ever be entitled to would be the divestiture of 31” of Tegna’s stations, Maynard said. “They presented no evidence that it was necessary to hold all of Tegna separate.” She argued the district court should have limited any hold-separate requirement to the roughly 31 stations in overlapping markets challenged by plaintiffs, while permitting integration of the rest.
The request comes after the Trump administration’s Justice Department and FCC approved the deal in March 2026, allowing Nexstar to close the acquisition almost immediately. The combination would create the nation’s largest local television operator, controlling stations reaching roughly 80% of U.S. households.
Satellite provider DirecTV and a coalition of state attorneys general sued, alleging the merger would substantially lessen competition, give Nexstar excessive leverage in retransmission-fee negotiations with pay-TV distributors, raise prices for consumers, and reduce local news diversity and quality.
In April, Judge Nunley issued a preliminary injunction and hold-separate order barring operational consolidation while the case proceeds. He scheduled a trial for July 2027 to decide whether the deal should be fully unwound. Nexstar has maintained that the injunction is overbroad, imposes “severe harm,” and prevents operational efficiencies and investments that would otherwise benefit stations facing competition from streaming platforms.
In April, Judge Nunley issued a preliminary injunction and hold-separate order barring operational consolidation while the case proceeds. He scheduled a trial for July 2027 to decide whether the deal should be fully unwound. Nexstar has maintained that the injunction is overbroad, imposes “severe harm,” and prevents operational efficiencies and investments that would otherwise benefit stations facing competition from streaming platforms.
During Tuesday’s hearing in Pasadena, the panel pressed on the practicalities of Nexstar’s proposed narrower remedy. U.S. Circuit Judge Marsha S. Berzon questioned what an injunction covering only a “rump Tegna” would look like, noting that “each station is an individual station. It’s not an individual financial entity,” and asking how a lower-court judge could ensure independent operation of the disputed stations within an otherwise integrated company. Counsel for California and other states argued that Nexstar had not shown how a smaller, independent Tegna could function effectively.
The 9th Circuit panel took the matter under submission and issued no immediate ruling. The underlying litigation, which also involves questions about board appointments and other integration steps already challenged as violating the hold-separate order, continues in the Eastern District of California. The outcome will shape not only the future of these two major station groups but also the broader landscape of local broadcast ownership as traditional television competes with digital and streaming platforms.
The merger received regulatory clearance from both the DOJ and the FCC. However, a bipartisan coalition of 13 state attorneys general—representing California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and Virginia—along with satellite provider DirecTV as a co-plaintiff, sued to block the combination. They allege it would substantially lessen competition in local television markets, reduce investment in local journalism, and give Nexstar excessive bargaining power that could drive up retransmission consent fees paid by cable and satellite distributors (costs that are often passed on to consumers).
Arguments Before the Panel
Judge Berzon pressed counsel for Nexstar and TEGNA for a clear picture of what the companies propose under the hold-separate framework, noting that the order does not treat any single financial entity as exempt. Nexstar is seeking to modify or narrow the injunction so it can begin integrating TEGNA’s operations while the case continues. The companies have pointed to practical challenges in running TEGNA’s stations independently, including under CEO Patrick Paolini (a former Fox Television Stations executive appointed in May) and a newly installed team of group general managers and local leaders for TEGNA’s 31 stations.
The state attorneys general and DirecTV argue that any significant integration would eliminate head-to-head competition between the two station groups, harm local news diversity, and strengthen Nexstar’s leverage in retransmission fee negotiations with pay-TV providers. They have urged the appeals court to keep the full injunction in place pending a trial, currently scheduled for 2027.
Arguments Before the Panel
Judge Berzon pressed counsel for Nexstar and TEGNA for a clear picture of what the companies propose under the hold-separate framework, noting that the order does not treat any single financial entity as exempt. Nexstar is seeking to modify or narrow the injunction so it can begin integrating TEGNA’s operations while the case continues. The companies have pointed to practical challenges in running TEGNA’s stations independently, including under CEO Patrick Paolini (a former Fox Television Stations executive appointed in May) and a newly installed team of group general managers and local leaders for TEGNA’s 31 stations.
The state attorneys general and DirecTV argue that any significant integration would eliminate head-to-head competition between the two station groups, harm local news diversity, and strengthen Nexstar’s leverage in retransmission fee negotiations with pay-TV providers. They have urged the appeals court to keep the full injunction in place pending a trial, currently scheduled for 2027.

