Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Catherine Herridge Urges SCOTUS to Review Reporter’s Privilege


Former Fox News investigative reporter Catherine Herridge filed a reply brief Tuesday urging the U.S. Supreme Court to take up a D.C. Circuit decision that limited the application of the reporter’s privilege in civil cases, warning that the ruling creates a “roadmap” for government officials to force journalists to unmask confidential sources through routine Privacy Act lawsuits.⁠

In the filing, Herridge’s legal team argued that if the lower court’s decision stands, it would chill First Amendment press freedoms. “The decision below provides a roadmap for every subject of an investigative exposé to compel the disclosure of the confidential sources involved,” the brief states. “Under the decision below, any disgraced official could file a Privacy Act lawsuit and compel the identification of a modern-day Deep Throat.”⁠

The case stems from Herridge’s 2017 reporting for Fox News on Yanping Chen, a Chinese-American businesswoman who founded the University of Management and Technology in Virginia, a school attended by U.S. military personnel. Herridge’s stories detailed an FBI counterintelligence investigation into Chen’s alleged ties to China’s People’s Liberation Army, including claims she had concealed that affiliation on immigration forms. Chen was never charged with any crime. The FBI later closed the investigation.

⁠

Yanping Chen
Chen sued the FBI and other federal agencies under the Privacy Act, alleging that government officials improperly leaked her protected records to Herridge. After discovery failed to identify the source of the information, Chen subpoenaed Herridge to compel her to name her confidential sources. Herridge refused, invoking a qualified First Amendment reporter’s privilege. In February 2024, U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper held her in civil contempt and ordered her to pay $800 per day until she complied. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit unanimously affirmed the contempt ruling in 2025, applying a narrow test that largely turns on whether the source’s identity is central to the plaintiff’s claim and whether other avenues have been exhausted—without broader balancing of public interests or national security concerns.⁠

Herridge, represented by former Solicitor General Paul Clement, petitioned the Supreme Court for review in August 2026, arguing that federal circuits are deeply divided on the scope of the reporter’s privilege in civil litigation more than 50 years after the Court’s decision in Branzburg v. Hayes. The Court earlier denied her emergency request for a stay of the contempt order (Justice Brett Kavanaugh would have granted it), though the daily fines have since been paused pending resolution of the certiorari petition. Multiple amicus briefs, including from press freedom groups, SAG-AFTRA, and Sens. Ted Cruz, Mike Lee, and Cynthia Lummis, have urged the justices to hear the case.

Fox News Media has continued to pay Herridge’s legal fees throughout the multi-year litigation, even after she left the network. The Supreme Court is expected to consider the petition in the coming weeks. 

If the D.C. Circuit’s approach is left undisturbed, press advocates warn it could make it significantly harder for journalists covering government misconduct—particularly in the nation’s capital—to protect the confidential sources essential to investigative reporting.