Wednesday, March 18, 2020
Judge Tosses Jury Verdict in Katy Perry Copyright Case
U.S. District Court Judge Christina Snyder found that Capitol Records and the team that worked on Perry’s “Dark Horse” in 2013 are not liable for infringing on Christian rapper Flame (né Marcus Gray)’s song, “Joyful Noise.”
After reviewing evidence presented at the initial trial in July, Snyder found that Gray failed the “extrinsic test,” which, according to The Hollywood Reporter, “requires that a copyright plaintiff identify concrete elements based on objective criteria that the works are similar.”
Without delving into the specific findings of Snyder and musicologist Todd Decker, it appears that the main “riff” to “Dark Horse” was Gray’s point of contention, and it was deemed insufficiently unique enough, reports The NYPost.
Perry, who announced she was pregnant in early March, could use some good news: Her grandmother died earlier in March, and she was forced to postpone her proposed Japanese nuptials with fiancé Orlando Bloom due to the coronavirus.
Posted 1:16:00 AM