Audiences of major U.S. news organizations differ not only in their political leanings and educational backgrounds but also in how they participate in public life, according to a recent analysis by the Pew Research Center as part of the Pew-Knight Initiative.
The study combined audience data from 30 prominent news outlets with findings from a broader examination of civic and social engagement among Americans. Researchers categorized news consumers into four engagement groups: Mobilizers, Connectors, Spectators and Outsiders.
Overall, the analysis found that Americans who are more engaged in public life are disproportionately represented in the audiences of many news organizations. Researchers noted that this is unsurprising, given that news consumption itself was one of the factors used to define the engagement categories.
News outlets with extensive political coverage were especially likely to attract Mobilizers, the group identified as the most politically active. While Mobilizers make up just 9% of the U.S. population, they account for 19% of regular news consumers of Axios, more than double their share among Americans overall.
By contrast, Outsiders, who represent 31% of the U.S. population, make up a similar proportion of the audiences for major television news providers, including ABC News, CBS News, NBC News, CNN and Fox News.
The study also found that Connectors, a group highly engaged in many aspects of public life but less active in politics, are overrepresented across most news audiences. Many organizations that attract large shares of Mobilizers also draw significant numbers of Connectors.
Nationally, 28% of Americans are classified as Connectors. However, that figure rises to 47% among regular consumers of The Atlantic and 45% among those who get news from The Hill. Connectors also account for 44% of the audiences of Breitbart, HuffPost and Politico, well above the national average.
Despite consuming news at rates comparable to Connectors, Spectators are underrepresented in the audiences of many news outlets. Researchers identified several notable exceptions.
Among regular consumers of The Joe Rogan Experience, 37% are categorized as Spectators, compared with 31% of U.S. adults overall. Spectators also comprise 36% of Telemundo’s audience and 40% of Univision’s audience.
According to the analysis, this pattern is linked in part to demographic differences. Hispanic Americans are more likely than non-Hispanic White or Black Americans to be classified as Spectators, with 44% falling into the category, compared with 26% of White Americans and 35% of Black Americans.
The findings highlight how news audiences vary not only in who they are, but also in how they engage with their communities, civic institutions and public affairs.
By contrast, Outsiders, who represent 31% of the U.S. population, make up a similar proportion of the audiences for major television news providers, including ABC News, CBS News, NBC News, CNN and Fox News.
The study also found that Connectors, a group highly engaged in many aspects of public life but less active in politics, are overrepresented across most news audiences. Many organizations that attract large shares of Mobilizers also draw significant numbers of Connectors.
Nationally, 28% of Americans are classified as Connectors. However, that figure rises to 47% among regular consumers of The Atlantic and 45% among those who get news from The Hill. Connectors also account for 44% of the audiences of Breitbart, HuffPost and Politico, well above the national average.
Despite consuming news at rates comparable to Connectors, Spectators are underrepresented in the audiences of many news outlets. Researchers identified several notable exceptions.
Among regular consumers of The Joe Rogan Experience, 37% are categorized as Spectators, compared with 31% of U.S. adults overall. Spectators also comprise 36% of Telemundo’s audience and 40% of Univision’s audience.
According to the analysis, this pattern is linked in part to demographic differences. Hispanic Americans are more likely than non-Hispanic White or Black Americans to be classified as Spectators, with 44% falling into the category, compared with 26% of White Americans and 35% of Black Americans.
The findings highlight how news audiences vary not only in who they are, but also in how they engage with their communities, civic institutions and public affairs.


