The Speculation Begins: Who Gets The Vacant Chair On The Five?

Speculation about who will replace Judge Jeanine Pirro on The Five after her departure on May 8, 2025, to serve as interim U.S. Attorney for Washington, D.C., has included several Fox News personalities, but no definitive replacement has been confirmed. 

Fox News stated that a rotation of network hosts will temporarily fill Pirro’s seat (on the left) until a permanent co-host is selected. Below is an overview of notable Fox News hosts who have been mentioned in speculation or are prominent figures within the network, based on available information and their potential fit for The Five’s dynamic:

• 
  Katie Pavlich: A Fox News contributor, Townhall editor, and frequent guest host on The Five, Pavlich is a strong candidate due to her conservative commentary and familiarity with the show’s format. Her alignment with the network’s right-leaning audience makes her a natural fit to maintain Pirro’s outspoken style.
• Kayleigh McEnany: The former Trump White House press secretary and current Fox News host has filled in on The Five multiple times. Her high-profile MAGA credentials and experience as a co-host on Outnumbered position her as a leading contender, especially given Pirro’s Trump-aligned persona.
• Kellyanne Conway: A Trump adviser and occasional Fox News contributor, Conway has previously substituted on The Five. Her political experience and media presence make her a viable option, though her current role as a contributor may limit her availability.
• Rachel Campos-Duffy: Co-host of Fox & Friends Weekend and a frequent Fox News commentator, Campos-Duffy has been noted for her conservative takes, as seen in discussions on voter sentiment. Her marriage to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, another Fox alum, adds to her network prominence, though she hasn’t been directly linked to The Five speculation.
• Joe Concha: A Fox News contributor praised by Trump for his book The Greatest Comeback Ever, Concha has appeared on shows like Fox & Friends First. While not explicitly tied to The Five, his rising profile and Trump’s endorsement make him a potential dark horse, especially if the network seeks a media critic.

Stay Tuned!.